Skip to main content
RealTime Wire
HealthIndia

Breaking the Silence: Advocating for Living Wills in India

India confronts the taboo of discussing death as health advocates promote understanding of living wills.

Source: bbc.co.uk3 min read
Breaking the Silence: Advocating for Living Wills in India
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

The growing movement seeks to empower individuals with choices regarding end-of-life care amidst a culture resistant to such conversations.

In 2010, a profound personal experience compelled Dr. IP Yadev, a surgeon from Kerala, to reevaluate the complex dynamics of end-of-life decisions in India. Faced with the terminal illness of his father, Dr. Yadev was burdened with the painful choice of prolonging life through medical intervention or honoring his father's expressed wishes for a dignified end. The ordeal culminated in his father's solitary death in an intensive care unit, a painful reminder of the need for clarity in end-of-life care. This turning point in Dr. Yadev's life ignited his commitment to advocating for living wills, which legally empower individuals over 18 to articulate their preferences for medical treatment if they become incapacitated. Living wills reflect personal choices, such as the refusal of life support or the desire for adequate pain relief, allowing patients to avoid unwanted medical interventions. In 2018, India's Supreme Court legalized living wills, permitting passive euthanasia under strict regulations. However, despite this legal framework, the concept has struggled to gain traction due to cultural sentiments around death. Traditionally viewed as a taboo, discussions about dying often invoke superstitions and fears of bad fortune. To confront these challenges, Dr. Yadev and his team initiated a groundbreaking outreach program at the Government Medical College in Kollam, Kerala. This initiative involved educating the public about living wills, conducting awareness campaigns, and offering templates for drafting these documents. Volunteers are playing an integral role in fostering open conversations about end-of-life care, despite societal resistance. Kerala is at the forefront of this movement, boasting an advanced palliative care network that supports dying with dignity. Organizations dedicated to end-of-life care have begun to mobilize efforts to normalize discussions about living wills. Recently, over 30 individuals from the Pain and Palliative Care society in Thrissur signed living wills, a gesture that signifies the building interest among the educated classes in Kerala. Dr. E Divakaran, the founder of the society, remarked on the widespread lack of familiarity with the term "living will," stressing the urgency for awareness about its procedures and implications. Nonetheless, a growing demographic, particularly among those in their 50s and 60s, is expressing interest in utilizing living wills. Dr. Yadev envisions a broader reach for the initiative, aiming to engage various social strata through campaigns at the grassroots level. Despite the existence of guidelines, the lack of effective mechanisms to implement living wills remains a challenge; many states, including Maharashtra, have only recently put custodians in place. Dr. Nikhil Datar, a gynecologist from Mumbai, found this out firsthand when he attempted to file his living will. After taking legal action, he was instrumental in appointing custodians to streamline the process for future applicants. With Goa and Karnataka making strides towards implementing the Supreme Court's directives, a national movement is slowly developing. Beyond solely facilitating passive euthanasia, living wills address broader healthcare preferences, such as the wish for life support under specific circumstances. Dr. Yadev recalls a poignant case where a father's will stipulated life support until his overseas son could visit, exemplifying how personalized directives can impact choices surrounding death and dying. Healthcare advocates are increasingly optimistic about the conversations surrounding palliative care, as institutions begin to implement educational programs for patients about living wills. Dr. Sushma Bhatnagar from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences highlights the necessity for healthcare professionals to engage patients in these critical discussions, emphasizing that patient autonomy should prevail even in the context of end-of-life decisions. As society grapples with the implications of death and dying, advocates encourage individuals to reclaim their rights to choose how they wish to navigate their final moments. "In life, our choices reflect the desires of others,” reflects Dr. Yadev. “In death, let us assert control over our own choices."

Topics

More on this story